Sermon – Over the Top
(I preached this sermon at Christ Lutheran Church in Harrisburg, PA on Sunday November 1, 2026, All Saints Sunday. The sermon is based on 1 Kings 3:4-28. You can listen to the audio through this link.)
Politics is something like a first language for me. Before I was a pastor, I spent years working on political campaigns. Here’s something that might surprise you. Religion and politics have a lot in common. Both offer a picture of a future that might be possible.
You know how a campaign ad works. Your candidate is shaking hands with the right people and listening to an older woman at the senior center. If you can get a puppy in the shot, even better. They are the only one who truly understands you. Your opponent gets the worst picture you can find, maybe their driver’s license photo, and a nickname that sticks. Normal doesn’t get attention. Over the top does.
This Tuesday is Election Day, and most of us have had our fill of over the top this fall. So hold onto that feeling, and listen to how the Bible introduces King Solomon.
Solomon has just become king after his father David. He goes up to Gibeon to worship, and he offers a thousand burnt offerings. A thousand. That night God comes to him in a dream and hands him a blank check. “Ask what I should give you.”
Solomon asks for wisdom. The Hebrew words he uses are beautiful. He asks for a lev shomea. A listening heart. In the Bible the heart is where you think and decide, so Solomon is asking for a mind that knows how to listen. He wants to hear the difference between good and evil so he can lead God’s people well.
That is a good request. It is the request we wish every leader would make, no matter what they lead. A president or a mayor. A school principal or the person running the night shift. Lord, give me a heart that listens.
God loves the answer. God gives him wisdom, and then God throws in riches and honor besides, more than any king who ever lived. And then God adds one more gift, with a little word attached. “If you walk in my ways, I will give you a long life.”
Remember that little word if. It is going to matter.
Then comes the story that is supposed to show us how wise Solomon is. Two women come before the king. The Bible calls them prostitutes. They live in the same house, and each of them had a baby. One baby died in the night. Now both women claim the living child. There are no witnesses. It is her word against her word.
Solomon calls for a sword. “Cut the living boy in two. Give half to each.”
One woman cries out, “Please, my lord, give her the baby. Just don’t kill him!” The other one says, “Go ahead. It won’t be mine or yours.” And Solomon says, “Give the child to the first woman. She is his mother.” All Israel hears about it and stands in awe.
I’ll be honest with you. The more times I read this story, the more it bothers me.
Think about who these women are. Life has pushed them to the very edge. Maybe they were desperately poor. Maybe someone else was profiting from their bodies. We know something about that in this neighborhood. We have watched it happen on the corner across the street from this church.
Solomon has all the power in the kingdom. He settles the argument, and then he sends them home. Back to the same house and the same life. Nobody asks how they got there. Nobody asks what they need.
And look at how he settles it. There is no investigation. There are no questions. There is a sword and a whole lot of fear. It’s clever. I’ll give him that. But clever and wise are two different things. We don’t even know if the right woman went home with the baby. Maybe the woman who begged for his life wasn’t his mother at all. Maybe she was simply the one who couldn’t stand to watch a baby die.
Here’s what I notice. The wisest moment in this whole story belongs to her. A woman the world had already thrown away was willing to lose the child she loved so that he could live. That is a listening heart. She had no crown and no sword. She had a love that put the child first. And it is her love that Solomon gets credit for.
The next chapter turns the volume up even more. Solomon’s wisdom is as vast as the sand on the seashore. He writes three thousand proverbs and over a thousand songs. Kings come from all over the earth just to hear him talk. He has forty thousand stalls for his horses, and later we learn he has seven hundred wives and three hundred more women besides.
It sounds a lot like a campaign ad.
It also sounds like the spin that comes after the election is won, no matter which party is in charge. The press secretary steps up to the podium. We’ve never had it so good. This is the greatest economy in history. Unemployment is the lowest it has been in fifty years. We have the strongest military the world has ever seen. You have heard lines like these from Republicans and Democrats alike, from one White House after another. We just tend to remember whoever said it most recently. Every claim has to be bigger than the last one.
When everything is huge, nothing is big anymore. People stop listening, because the words are empty.
The writer of First Kings seems to know this. Page after page, the praise for Solomon keeps getting louder. Then the writer lets us see what the press release left out.
Underneath all that shine, Solomon has been running up a bill. He builds the temple and a palace for himself with forced labor. Put it on the tab. The taxes get heavier. Put it on the tab. He brings in horses and chariots from Egypt, the very place God brought the people out of. He marries wives from other nations, and little by little his heart turns toward their gods. Item after item goes on the bill. And then the bill comes due. That little word if.
When Solomon dies, the people go to his son and say, “Your father made our load heavy. Please make it lighter.” His son looks at that bill and decides he can just keep adding to it. “My father made it heavy? I’ll make it heavier.” And the kingdom breaks in two.
Last week, with David and Bathsheba, I reminded you of God’s warning in 1 Samuel. When the people demanded a king like the other nations had, God told them a king will take. He will take your sons and daughters, your fields and your harvest. Then we watched David become that king, when he took Bathsheba and then took her husband’s life.
Solomon, the wisest king who ever lived, became that king too. Just like his father. Just like every king and emperor, every tyrant and strongman, who decides he is the final word and doesn’t have to answer to anybody.
So why would the Bible tell the story this way? Why lift Solomon up so high, only to let him fall?
Most scholars believe these books came together during the exile. Babylon had destroyed Jerusalem. The temple Solomon built was rubble. God’s people had been dragged hundreds of miles from home. Imagine sitting in a strange land, far from everything you knew, asking, “How did we end up here?” First and Second Kings are the long answer to that question. They tell the slow slide, king after king, of a people who kept breaking faith with a God who kept faith with them, until the land itself was gone.
Was the over the top Solomon royal propaganda, or a setup for the fall? Maybe both. We don’t have to settle that this morning. The Bible can handle our questions. What I notice is that the Bible refuses to leave Solomon on his pedestal. It tells the truth about him. One commentator I read this week put it this way: maybe Solomon’s listening heart simply stopped listening. A gift from God can be forgotten when we stop paying attention to the Giver.
The Bible has a word for the life God wants for us. Shalom. We usually translate it as peace, but it means a life where everyone has enough. Solomon’s kingdom had far too much at the top and far too little at the bottom. Those two women in the story show us what the bottom looked like.
We live in an over the top age too. The louder the headline, the more people click. Our phones are built to keep us angry, because angry people keep scrolling. We hit the angry face on a post, type a line or two about people we have never met, call them enemies, and say they are out to destroy the country.
We live in a time when it feels like words are failing us. Cruelty and violence happen. Injustice and corruption happen right out in the open. And there are no words big enough to name what this moment really is.
At the same time, there are always plenty of words to excuse it. There is always an explanation, always a spin. Those words cover over an emptiness. They cover the hollow place in the soul where right and wrong are supposed to live.
None of this is new. About a hundred and fifty years ago, this country went through the Gilded Age. A few men built fortunes beyond imagining while workers, children among them, labored in the mills and mines for pennies. Something gilded has a thin coat of gold on the outside. Underneath, it can be rotting.
That can be true of things. It can also be true of a person, or a whole people, down in the soul. An age of too much is really an age that is badly out of balance. There is too much wealth piled up at the top, and a terrible poverty of goodness and decency. And rot that nobody tends keeps spreading.
So where are the listening hearts of our age? So much of our creativity right now goes into imagining how everything falls apart. Who is painting a picture of God’s future, where the hungry are fed, the sick get care, kids can walk to school safely, and neighbors know each other’s names? And who is showing us how we get there?
That brings me to Tuesday.
I know a lot of us are carrying this election in our bodies. We’re anxious. There are so many questions nobody can answer yet. What happens to my health care? What happens to my neighbor who came here from another country? And a lot of us are angry at the state of this country and at the people in charge, often for good reason.
Bring all of that to God. The psalms are full of people telling God exactly how scared and angry they are. God can handle it. You don’t have to pretend in here.
Here is my pastoral worry for us. We tend to do with candidates exactly what this story does with Solomon. When our person wins, we build them up until their wisdom is like the sand on the seashore. We expect them to fix everything. Then they let us down, because no human being could ever carry that much. When the other person wins, we turn them into a monster capable of anything.
Either way, we have made something in our own image and asked it to save us. The Bible has a word for that too. An idol. Solomon fell into idol worship. We can fall into it too, with a name on a yard sign.
Here’s the hard part. Leaders are human beings, the same as us. If you look honestly inside your own heart, you will find both possibilities there. You’ll find a flawed person with real limits, trying with some humility and compassion to do the best you can. You’ll also find the capacity to be cruel, to cut corners, to hurt someone on purpose when it serves you. I’m not saying you will. I’m saying it’s there. It’s in me too. That is part of being human.
Some leaders lean toward compassion. Some choose cruelty and corruption again and again, on purpose. Solomon did. He built God’s temple on the backs of forced laborers. The Bible doesn’t excuse that, and neither should we. Injustice deserves to be called injustice, whoever does it.
When we see our own humanity clearly, we start to see leaders differently. We stop making excuses for cruelty, and we stop making monsters out of people. We see what is real, and then we choose a different way forward. We refuse to become what we oppose. We stay honest with God about our fear and our anger. And we get to work moving whatever we can toward God’s vision. A meal served. A neighbor welcomed. A call to a lawmaker. A ride to the polls.
You could say we are all campaigners now. We are out knocking on doors for God’s future, where the hungry are fed and the stranger is welcome. And that campaign doesn’t end on Tuesday night.
So go vote. Have your say. It is a gift that a lot of people in this world don’t have. Watch the results if you want to. And guard your hearts. Guard them from the high of winning and from the despair of losing. Both of those are too much.
So if our hope can’t rest on whoever wins on Tuesday, where does it rest?
Go back to those exiles in Babylon, asking how they ended up there. Second Kings ends with Jerusalem in ruins. But the prophet Ezekiel, sitting in exile with his people, sees a vision. God sets him down in a valley full of dry bones and asks, “Mortal, can these bones live?” Ezekiel says the only honest thing he can say. “O Lord God, you know.” Then God breathes, and the bones rattle together and stand up, a whole living crowd. And God says, “I will open your graves, my people, and bring you home.”
Here is the good news. Notice who does that. There is no king in that valley. Nobody is campaigning, and nobody is on a ballot. The hope of God’s people never came from a throne. It came from the breath of God.
That same breath of God raised Jesus from the dead. And Jesus will never be on a ballot. Honestly, that’s a good thing, because I doubt he would win. Look at his platform. Love your enemies. Welcome the stranger, even the one who didn’t come in the “right way,” whatever that means. Stop hoarding wealth. Care for the sick without checking first whether they deserve it. Eat with the people everyone else avoids. Bring good news to the poor and freedom to the captives. Any campaign consultant would tell him to tone it down. They would also tell him to go on the attack and paint his enemies as monsters. Jesus had every chance. At his trial he could have torn into Pilate and the priests. On the cross he could have cursed the empire that was killing him. Instead he prayed, “Father, forgive them, for they do not know what they are doing.”
Why is that platform so unpopular? I have been wrestling with this one. What I hear more and more is people caring about themselves first, and sometimes only about themselves. The loudest complaint I hear about the war in Iran is the price of gas. I hear far less about the people who are dying. And I keep wondering, if gas were still cheap, would anyone object at all?
I know that sounds harsh. But I see it again and again. I read comments online cheering when other people get deported or lose their jobs. They had it coming, people say. Then some of those same folks are posting in shock because ICE took someone they love, or because they were the one who got laid off. Suddenly they see it. Suddenly it’s cruel.
Why does it take something happening to us before we can see the injustice? I wish Solomon, with all his wisdom, could explain that to me. I honestly can’t make sense of it.
Here’s what I do know. Jesus’ platform is unpopular because it leaves no room for a shrug. In the kingdom of God, there is no “them” we get to ignore. The family being deported and the worker who lost a job. The people living under the bombs and the woman on the corner across the street. All of them are us. There is only us.
Solomon asked for wisdom, and God gave it to him. Over time he squandered it. He forgot the gift, and he forgot the Giver.
Jesus had none of what Solomon had. He had no palace and no army. He never owned a horse, let alone forty thousand of them. When he rode into Jerusalem, it was on a borrowed donkey. And yet he had so much more. He had a love that would not quit. He brought shalom everywhere he went. He brought good news to the poor and freedom to people in chains. He healed the sick and fed the hungry. He cared for people nobody else would touch, and he lifted them up so they could stand on their own.
Once, after he fed a huge crowd, the people tried to grab him and make him king by force. He slipped away up the mountain by himself. The only crown he ever wore was made of thorns. Solomon took from his people. Jesus gave himself for his people.
Solomon built amazing buildings. The temple took seven years. His own palace took thirteen. In the end, Babylon burned them both to the ground.
Jesus built a life. That life is still touching people today, two thousand years later. It’s like a pebble dropped in a pond. The ripples keep spreading, wider and wider, all the way out to Allison Hill. Every time a patient walks into one of our clinics and is cared for without question, that is one of those ripples.
Buildings come and go. Love lasts forever. We don’t tell stories about buildings. Buildings hold the stories, and the stories outlast the buildings. The stories are always about people and how they lived. Sometimes the stories are beautiful. Sometimes they are ugly.
Solomon may have been wise. He was still not God. Our hope rests on Jesus, the King who gives himself away.
Today is also the day we remember the saints. In a little while you will be invited to come forward, hold a name in your heart, and light a candle for someone you have loved who has died.
This building has held a lot of stories since it went up in 1920. Thousands of people once filled these pews. Then there were only seven. And God was not finished with this place. Every story these walls hold is a story about people.
I want you to notice something about those names. None of them is Solomon. None of them wrote a thousand songs. Most of them never made the news. A grandmother who prayed for you every single night. An uncle who fixed everybody’s car for free. A neighbor who always had an extra plate when you were hungry. Members of this congregation who kept these doors open when hardly anyone was left.
Were they perfect? You know they weren’t. Martin Luther said we are saints and sinners at the same time. Solomon was. Your grandmother was. I am. So are you. What makes someone a saint is God, who claims us in baptism and holds on to us, even when we forget, even when we wander off the way Solomon did.
And so many of the people we remember today had the very thing Solomon asked for and then lost. They had listening hearts. They noticed who was hurting. They paid attention to the kid who was quiet and the neighbor who was struggling. That is wisdom. It is the kind of wisdom nobody ever puts on a billboard.
When you light your candle today, you are remembering someone. You are not the one keeping them alive. God is. The people we love rest in the same promise Ezekiel saw in that valley. “I will open your graves, my people.” Death doesn’t get the last word. Exile doesn’t get the last word. And no election, on Tuesday or ever, gets the last word. God does.
If God came to you tonight in a dream and said, “Ask what I should give you,” what would you ask for?
Maybe we could ask for what Solomon asked for. A listening heart. For ourselves, for our neighbors, and for whoever wins on Tuesday.
And here is the best news of all. We don’t have to wait around for a wise king to save us. God has already sent one. The apostle Paul calls Jesus the wisdom of God. Jesus is the one whose heart never stops listening. He hears the woman nobody believes. He hears the mother begging for her child’s life. He hears the names you whisper as you light your candle today. And he hears you.
Solomon’s kingdom ran up a bill that came due. Jesus’ kingdom runs on grace. Nothing goes on the tab. He has already given everything, and he holds on to us and to everyone we love, in life and in death.
At the end of worship, we will pray for our nation and for this election. Then we will go out those doors. On Tuesday, go vote. And on Wednesday morning, whatever happened the night before, Jesus will still be Lord. The clinics will still open their doors. And God will still be breathing life into dry bones.
Thanks be to God. Amen.